One-line summary:
“This Is How It Always Is” is a heartwarming and thought-provoking novel that explores the challenges and triumphs of a family navigating the complexities of gender identity.
Introduction:
“This Is How It Always Is” by Laurie Frankel is a captivating and emotionally charged novel that delves into the journey of a family as they navigate the complexities of gender identity. Through the lens of the Walsh-Adams family, Frankel explores the themes of love, acceptance, and the power of unconditional support. With a perfect blend of humor, heartbreak, and hope, this novel challenges societal norms and encourages readers to question their own perceptions of gender.
Discovering Claude’s True Identity:
The story revolves around Rosie and Penn Walsh-Adams, a loving couple raising five boys in Madison, Wisconsin. When their youngest son, Claude, expresses a desire to wear dresses and identifies as a girl, the family embarks on a journey of self-discovery and acceptance. Initially, Rosie and Penn dismiss it as a phase, but as Claude’s insistence grows, they realize that their child’s gender identity is not something that can be ignored or changed.
As Claude transitions into Poppy, the family grapples with the challenges and complexities that arise. They face the judgment of others, encounter difficulties in finding the right school environment, and navigate the legal and medical aspects of transitioning. Through it all, the Walsh-Adams family remains united, determined to support Poppy in her journey to live authentically.
Unconditional Love and Acceptance:
Throughout the novel, Frankel emphasizes the importance of unconditional love and acceptance within a family. Rosie and Penn’s unwavering support for Poppy is a testament to their commitment as parents. They create a safe space for Poppy to explore her identity, allowing her to express herself freely and without judgment. The family’s love for one another shines through as they face the challenges together, demonstrating the power of acceptance in fostering a sense of belonging and happiness.
Challenging Societal Norms:
“This Is How It Always Is” challenges societal norms surrounding gender identity and raises important questions about the limitations of binary thinking. Frankel skillfully explores the complexities of gender, highlighting the fluidity and individuality of each person’s experience. The novel encourages readers to question preconceived notions and embrace a more inclusive understanding of gender.
Key Takeaways:
- Unconditional love and acceptance are vital in supporting individuals exploring their gender identity.
- Challenging societal norms and embracing a more inclusive understanding of gender is essential for fostering a more accepting society.
- Open communication and education are crucial in navigating the complexities of gender identity.
“Sometimes, she worried about what would happen if Poppy changed her mind. But then she thought, what if she didn’t? What if she was right? What if Poppy was right? What if they were all right? What if it didn’t matter?”
Conclusion:
“This Is How It Always Is” is a powerful and poignant novel that explores the complexities of gender identity within the context of a loving and supportive family. Laurie Frankel’s storytelling captures the challenges, triumphs, and heartache that accompany the journey of self-discovery. Through the Walsh-Adams family, readers are reminded of the importance of unconditional love, acceptance, and the need to challenge societal norms. This thought-provoking novel encourages readers to embrace a more inclusive understanding of gender and to approach the topic with empathy and compassion.
